| Year | Horse | Sire - Dam - Dam's Sire |
| 2009 | Rachel Alexandra | Medaglia 'dOro - Lotta Kim by Roar |
| 2008 | Proud Spell | Proud Citizen - Pacific Spell by Langfuhr |
| 2007 | Rags to Riches | A.P. Indy - Better Than Honour by Deputy Minister |
| 2006 | Lemons Forever | Lemon Drop Kid - Critikola by Tough Critic |
| 2005 | Summerly | Summer Squall - Here I Go by Mr. Prospector |
| 2004 | Ashado | Saint Ballado - Goulash by Mari's Book |
| 2003 | Bird Town | Cape Town - Dear Birdie by Storm Bird |
| 2002 | Farda Amiga | Broad Brush - Fly North |
| 2001 | Flute | Seattle Slew - Rougeur |
| 2000 | Secret Status | A.P. Indy - Private Status |
| 1999 | Silverbulletday | Silver Deputy - Rokeby Rose |
| 1998 | Keeper Hill | Deputy Minister - Fineza |
| 1997 | Blushing K. D. | Blushing John - Lilac Garden |
| 1996 | Pike Place Dancer | Seattle Dancer - Vana Turns |
| 1995 | Gal in a Ruckus | Bold Ruckus - Quillummo |
| 1994 | Sardula | Storm Cat - Honor an Offer |
| 1993 | Dispute | Danzig - Resolver |
| 1992 | Luv Me Luv Me Not | It's Freezing - Reason With Me |
| 1991 | Lite Light | Majestic Light - Printing Press |
| 1990 | Seaside Attraction | Seattle Slew - Kamar |
| 1989 | Open Mind | Deputy Minister - Stage Luck |
| 1988 | Goodbye Halo | Halo - Pound Foolish |
| 1987 | Buryyourbelief | Believe It - Bury the Hatchet |
| 1986 | Tiffany Lass | Bold Forbes - Sally Stark |
| 1985 | Fran's Valentine | Saros - Iza Valentine |
| 1984 | Lucky Lucky Lucky | Chieftain - Just One More Time |
| 1983 | Princess Rooney | Verbatim - Parrish Princess |
| 1982 | Blush With Pride | Blushing Groom - Best in Show |
| 1981 | Heavenly Cause | Grey Dawn II - Lady Dulcinea |
| 1980 | Bold 'n Determined | Bold and Brave - Pidi |
| 1979 | Davona Dale | Best Turn - Royal Entrance |
| 1978 | White Star Line | Northern Dancer - Fast Line |
| 1977 | Sweet Alliance | Sir Ivor - Mrs. Peterkin |
| 1976 | Optimistic Gal | Sir Ivor - Hopes Ahead |
| 1975 | Sun and Snow | Hawaii - Alpine Peak |
| 1974 | Quaze Quilt | Specialmante - Quaze |
| 1973 | Bag of Tunes | Herbager - Swoon's Tune |
| 1972 | Susan's Girl | Quadrangle - Quaze |
| 1971 | Silent Beauty | Creme dela Creme - Village Beauty |
| 1970 | Lady Vi-E. | Swaps - Simona |
| 1969 | Hail to Patsy | Hail to Reason - Elysium |
| 1968 | Dark Mirage | Persian Road II - Home By Dark |
| 1967 | Nancy Jr. | Tim Tam - Bank Account |
| 1966 | Native Street | Native Dancer - Beaver Street |
| 1965 | Amerivan | Amerigo - In the Van |
| 1964 | Blue Norther | Windy City II - Perfect Gem |
| 1963 | Sally Ship | Turn-to - Nut Brown Maid |
| 1962 | Cicada | Bryan G. - Satsuma |
| 1961 | My Portrait | Ambiorix - Anchors Aweigh |
| 1960 | Make Sail | Olympia - Me |
| 1959 | Wedlock (1st div) | Dark Star - Dangerous Dame |
| 1959 | Hidden Talent(2nddiv) | Rough'n Tumble - Softie |
| 1958 | Bug Brush | Nasrullah - Bonnie Beryl |
| 1957 | Lori-El | Eternal Reward - Trefoil |
| 1956 | Princess Turia | Heliopolis - Blue Delight |
| 1955 | Lalun | Djeddah - Be Faithful |
| 1954 | Fascinator | War Jeep - Miracle Sister |
| 1953 | Bubbley | Bull Lea - Blue Delight |
| 1952 | Real Delight | Bull Lea - Blue Delight |
| 1951 | How | Princequillo - The Squaw II |
| 1950 | Ari's Mona | Kings Blue - Arianna |
| 1949 | Wistful | Sun Again - Easy Lass |
| 1948 | Challe Anne | Challedon - Victorious Ann |
| 1947 | Blue Grass | Blue Larkspur - Camelot |
| 1946 | First Page | Johnstown - Cozy Time |
| 1945 | Come and Go | Epithet - Set Fast |
| 1944 | Canina | Bull Dog - Coronium |
| 1943 | Nellie L. | Blenheim II - Nellie Flag |
| 1942 | Miss Dogwood | Bull Dog - Myrtlewood |
| 1941 | Valdina Myth | Sortie - Sweep Myth |
| 1940 | Inscolassie | Insco - Margaret Lawrence |
| 1939 | Flying Lill | Flying Heels - Laila Wild |
| 1938 | Flying Lee | Pennant - Hilee |
| 1937 | Mars Shield | Diavolo - Escutcheon |
| 1936 | Two Bob | The Porter - Blessings |
| 1935 | Paradisical | In Memoriam - Madrigal |
| 1934 | Fiji | Bostonian - O Girl |
| 1933 | Barn Swallow | Black Servant - Blue Warbler |
| 1932 | Suntica | Sun Briar - Simpatica |
| 1931 | Cousin Jo | Stimulus - Gentle Julia |
| 1930 | Alcibiades | Supremus - Regal Roman |
| 1929 | Rose of Sharon | Light Brigade - Rosa Mundi |
| 1928 | Easter Stockings | Sir Barton - Irish Lassie |
| 1927 | Mary Jane | Pennant - Bourbon Lass |
| 1926 | Black Maria | Black Toney - Bird Loose |
| 1925 | Deeming | Spanish Prince II - Pin Feather |
| 1924 | Princess Doreen** | Spanish Prince II - Lady Doreen |
| 1923 | Untidy | Sweep - Cafe au Lait |
| 1922 | Startle | Star Hawk - Inspiration |
| 1921 | Nancy Lee | Broomstick - Naughty Lady |
| 1920 | Lorraine | Ben Brush - Amy J. |
| 1919 | Lillian Shaw | Fair Play - Early Love |
| 1918 | Viva America | McGee - Pink Rose |
| 1917 | *Sunbonnet | Sunstar - Marian Hood |
| 1916 | Kathleen | Sempronius - Boema |
| 1915 | Waterblossom | Waterboy - Basseting |
| 1914 | Bronzewing | Stalwart - Miss Dolly |
| 1913 | Cream | Electioneer - Ambrosia |
| 1912 | Flamma | Hastings - Flittermouse |
| 1911 | Bettie Sue | The Commoner - Alveria M. |
| 1910 | Samaria | Kilkerran - Tapiola |
| 1909 | Floreal | Alloway - Anyday |
| 1908 | Ellen-a-Dale | Alan-A-Dale - Queenlike II |
| 1907 | Wing Ting | Star Shoot - Van-a-Clar |
| 1906 | King's Daughter | Ornament - Queenlike II |
| 1905 | Janeta | Bob Miles - Laurel |
| 1904 | Audience | Sir Dixon - Sallie McClelland |
| 1903 | Lemco | Ducat - La Pomona |
| 1902 | Wainamoinen | The Commoner - Matilda |
| 1901 | Lady Schorr | Esher - War Mantle |
| 1900 | Etta | Falsetto - Manola |
| 1899 | Rush | Wadsworth - Reine D'Or |
| 1898 | Crocket | Linden - Crotchet |
| 1897 | White Frost | Iroquois - Wildflower |
| 1896 | Souffle | Rayon d'Or - Soncy Lass |
| 1895 | Voladora | Volante - Maori |
| 1894 | Selika | Spendthrift - Messmate |
| 1893 | Monrovia | Strathmore - Leap Frog |
| 1892 | Miss Dixie | Falsetto - Barbiche |
| 1891 | Miss Hawkins | Billet - Lady Motley |
| 1890 | English Lady | Miser - Bonny Lass |
| 1889 | Jewel Ban | King Ban - Jewel |
| 1888 | Ten Penny | Ten Broeck - Miss Nailer |
| 1887 | Florimore | Longfellow - Florac |
| 1886 | Pure Rye | Billet - Mary Clark |
| 1885 | Lizzie Dwyer | King Alfonso - Lilly Duke |
| 1884 | Modesty | War Dance - Ballet |
| 1883 | Vera | King Alfonso - Veritas |
| 1882 | Katie Creel | King Alfonso - Marguerite |
| 1881 | Lucy May | Buckden - Georgia Bowman |
| 1880 | Longitude | Longfellow - Fanny Malone |
| 1879 | Liahtunah | John Morgan - Lantana |
| 1878 | Belle of Nelson | Hunter's Lexington - Julia Mattingly |
| 1877 | Felicia | Phaeton - Farfaletta |
| 1876 | Neecy Hale | Lexington - Miriam |
| 1875 | Vinaigrette | Vandal - Liza Davis |
Check Out
